http://www.money.com/money/depts/investing/rebound/

Investing
When will stocks get going again?
 
 
It's rate cuts vs. overcapacity in a battle over the fate of the market.

By Suzanne Woolley

 
  Economic whiplash
  Dueling data
  Timing is everything
  Five visions, bright and dark

 
It's a bear market malady: economic whiplash. It seems as if every day brings some new batch of data giving conflicting signals on the economy and the market. Pundits zero in on the innocent statistics, poke them, prod them, and proclaim dueling interpretations. All the while, the stock market indexes do a great imitation of a bad liar taking a polygraph test. 
The highly technical question we all want answered: When will the stock market snap out of it? A decade-long bull market has left many of us ill-prepared to endure a sustained slump. Many investors and market analysts are experiencing their first significant economic downturn since they became enamored of equities. Small wonder that investing seems so daunting today. 

It's daunting because we are, in essence, caught in an economic tug-of-war. On one side we have vast overcapacity, plunging capital spending, falling earnings, and fears that unemployment, while low, will shoot up. On the other side, we have aggressive cuts in short-term interest rates by the Federal Reserve, tax-rebate checks, rebounding consumer confidence, rising personal income, and falling energy prices. 

Which side will prevail? Will the impact of rate cuts kick in soon enough to stave off a retrenching by consumers if unemployment spikes up? Or will a pullback in consumer spending and falling corporate earnings send stocks plunging and land the economy squarely in a textbook recession? 
 


Dueling data

There's plenty of evidence to support either scenario. Let's look at the bear case first. The manufacturing sector is in recession, with June's report on industrial production showing the ninth consecutive month of decline. The earnings season has been excruciating. In the second quarter, Thomson Financial/First Call estimates that S&P 500 earnings dropped 18.1 percent. That may turn out to be the worst year-over-year comparison since 1991's third quarter, when earnings plunged 17.9 percent. Also unsettling was the June employment report, which showed total nonfarm payroll employment falling by 114,000, reflecting slower growth in both manufacturing and service payrolls. To cap it off, a strong dollar is hurting corporate profits by making U.S. goods less competitive, partially offsetting the benefit of rate cuts. 
Now here's the good news. The Conference Board's U.S. Leading Economic Index rose for the third straight month in June (the index measures 10 factors such as money supply, average weekly initial claims for unemployment insurance, and building permits). Inflation appears quiescent. Meanwhile, consumer spending remains surprisingly resilient. Auto sales have been particularly good, and home sales remain strong. 

But the most important fact by far, for those who believe that the market is on its way to recovery, is that the Federal Reserve has cut the short-term interest rates that it controls six times this year. Only once before has the Fed cut rates so dramatically in such a short period, and that was in 1982, when rates were higher than they are today. UBS Warburg chief global strategist Edward Kerschner is counting on the rate cuts to spur economic growth and expects that consumers will spend their tax rebates rather than put them under the mattress. "We have the most aggressive fiscal stimulus probably ever juxtaposed against aggressive monetary stimulus from the Fed," says Kerschner. "The question is, Do people really think that monetary and fiscal policy don't work? For a couple hundred years they have worked." 

Since we're becoming a Fed-centric society, let's consider what Fed chairman Alan Greenspan said in his semiannual monetary policy report to Congress. While Greenspan noted that "the period of subpar economic performance...is not yet over," and signaled that another rate cut is possible, he also observed that the Fed's "front-loaded policy actions this year coupled with the tax cuts under way should be increasingly affecting economic activity as the year progresses." Though hardly ebullient, he did note that "incoming data on economic activity have turned from persistently negative to more mixed." 



Timing is everything

If cheaper money is such powerful medicine, why haven't the economy and stock market responded already? Good question. Part of the answer is timing. It's been only six months since the Fed began this round of cuts, and it takes a while for the economy to feel the effect of lower rates. Historically, the economy begins to improve six to 12 months after the Fed starts cutting rates (although the market usually perks up before the economy does). This time, however, it may take longer, says Bank Credit Analyst managing editor Martin Barnes. He argues that when the Fed began cutting rates, monetary policy was tight (meaning that rates were high relative to inflation). It was only with the March rate cut, says Barnes, that monetary policy became truly "accommodative" -- which, in Fedspeak, means making credit more readily available. 
There are other factors that may mute the impact of rate cuts. One is the powerful head wind that rate cuts are fighting in the form of a very strong dollar. Typically, rate cuts lead to a weaker dollar, which helps brighten the export outlook and encourages U.S. consumers to buy more U.S. goods. But today the dollar remains strong, propped up in part by international investors who view it as the ultimate safe haven. 



Five visions, bright and dark

Even if rate cuts are not acting as fast as they have in the past, history strongly suggests that stocks will start to move higher soon. That still leaves the question of how soon -- and how much? With that in mind, we asked five investing gurus with varying degrees of optimism for their take on the market and where they see opportunity today. 
Marshall Acuff


Salomon Smith Barney strategist Acuff sees selected opportunities in stocks but expects the broad market to move up and down within a fairly narrow range. Sure, the Fed is increasing the money supply, providing fuel for a recovery, but Acuff thinks that the Fed's stimulus is being offset by continued cuts in corporate earnings forecasts, giving investors little reason to start loading up on stocks right now. 

In tech, Acuff says he's tempted by IBM, which has a big and growing proportion of its business coming from services rather than software and hardware. In general, says the strategist, "this is a market of singles and doubles at best, not home runs, and you have to do more homework than was necessary in the momentum days." 

Peter Canelo
 
 


Morgan Stanley strategist Canelo thinks the stock market hit bottom in March and April and will move sharply higher by the end of the year. "The Fed is being extra generous with lower interest rates, and tax rebates are a second stimulus," he says. "A major decline in energy prices will start becoming a reality later this summer, and that's another pseudo tax cut." 

After a nasty third-quarter earnings season, Canelo thinks the S&P 500 could hit 1425 to 1450 by the end of the year, a 20 percent gain from current levels, and he expects an S&P 500 earnings gain for the year of 12 to 13 percent. He is advising his clients to sift among retail stocks, since he expects that consumer spending will pick up, partly in response to lower interest rates. 

Abby Joseph Cohen


Goldman Sachs strategist Cohen, who pictures the market's path as a series of broad steps upward, says that the S&P 500 is undervalued but that "we're stuck at the bottom of the step." By year-end, says Cohen, "investors will feel better and will see no recession and want to own stocks again." She has targets of 1550 for the S&P 500 and 12,500 for the Dow. From current levels, that's a 28 percent gain for the S&P and an 18 percent gain for the Dow. 

Edward Kerschner
 
 


Much of the confusion in the market today should be dismissed as mere short-term noise, counsels Kerschner. "While everyone was panicking over every nickel and dime in the second-quarter earnings reports," he says, "I was on vacation thinking that when I came back we'd be much nearer to the bottom than when I left." 

Confident that a recovery is under way, Kerschner expects corporate earnings to show healthy operating gains of 11 to 13 percent by 2002. Investors can add another 5 percent or so, thanks to a rule change affecting the way corporations account for acquisitions, he adds. Mix in Kerschner's expectation that the dollar stays "flattish" in 2002, and so doesn't shave the 2 percent off corporate profits that the Fed estimates it will in 2001, and you've got reported earnings up 15 to 20 percent for 2002. 

Kerschner's picks include companies that he thinks will prove adept at "focusing on what they do best and spinning off or outsourcing everything else." That includes America Movil, Bank of New York, Deutsche Post, Diageo, Nestle, PepsiCo, and UPS. "Cyclical bottoms are a great time to buy the market," he says, "and it's hard to argue that we're not near a bottom." 

James Paulsen
 
 


A much darker reading of the economic tea leaves comes from James Paulsen, chief investment officer of Wells Capital Management. Paulsen expects the unemployment rate to spike up to 5 or 5.5 percent, resulting in a consumer pullback that leads to a recession lasting into next year. 

Paulsen, who expects inflation to remain under control, thinks the risk/reward equation currently favors bonds over stocks. He recommends sticking with high-quality bonds or bond-like stocks such as utilities, selected financials, and dividend-paying integrated oil stocks. "The inflation story is just wonderful for a bondholder," he says, "and I think it will get better with the dollar climbing." 



Copyright ? 2001 Time Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
Our Privacy Policy. Terms of use. Join the Money Affiliate Network
 
